Brooklyn Public Library

Mobile AppDownload our Mobile App

eNewsletterSubscribe to BPL eNews


Give a Man a Job!

Feb 12, 2009 10:59 AM | 9 comments

Last week a teacher asked me to find evidence of the New Deal in Brooklyn.  She is asking her students to complete a project on the Great Depression and compare it to the economic situation in Brooklyn today.

As my research progressed, I stumbled upon the story of the NRA, or National Recovery Administration, a New Deal initiative with direct ties to Brooklyn's past.  Started in 1933, the NRA (not to be confused with the Rifle Association), was one of President Roosevelt's first major efforts.  It was designed to enforce strategies that were set forth in the National Industrial Recovery Act.  NRA leaders helped industries create voluntary agreements over work hours, wages, and prices.  Businesses that abided by these regulations posted a blue eagle symbol in their window.  Consumers were encourage to patronize only these businesses.  It was hoped that this regulation would stabilize the economy and protect vulnerable consumers and employees.


Brooklyn, like many communities across the country, embraced the NRA with open arms.  In November of 1933, 15,000 men, women and children marched in the NRA Parade in Park Slope.  In Coney Island, staff members and volunteers held a pledge drive for NRA consumers.  Even theatergoers were reminded of the NRA's presence.  Brooklynites may have seen this promotional short starring Brooklyn born Jimmy Durante:


But not everyone was convinced by Mr. Durante's ardent patriotism.  Big businesses were handling much of the negotiations.  The Eagle even mentioned the "grave injustice" that the NRA was placing on certain small businesses.  The debates over the effectiveness of the NRA came to a head in July of 1934 when four brothers from Brooklyn were chosen to test the legal limitations of the NRA.  Joseph, Martin, Alex, and Aaron Schecter ran a live poultry market that catered to kosher butchers at 858 East 52nd Street. Their company, the Schechter Poultry Corporation, was charged with violating a series of NRA agreements.

The Eagle covered the legal proceedings in detail; it was the first NRA criminal prosecution in New York and only the third in the country.  In November, a local court found the brothers guilty and sentenced them to time in jail and a fine.  The brothers quickly began an appeal process that resulted in their appearance before the United States Supreme Court.

It was to be the NRA's first and last judicial test.  The brothers argued that the national government had no right to regulate their business because they only operated within New York State.  The Supreme Court unanimously agreed and declared that the NRA was unconstitutional.  With one decision, FDR's great patriotic initiative was gone.  President Roosevelt was severely disappointed in the ruling, and spent the following years criticizing the Court and trying to alter its political leanings.  He also worked to establish new administrations that repilicated the successful aspects of the NRA.

The Schechter brothers, however, were unable to enjoy the fruits of their labor.  They had accrued over $60,000 in legal fees and within a year had only paid off a third of that.  The business they had fought so hard to save was bankrupt.  By 1936, three of the brothers had found alternative employment, but Joseph was still out of work.  His wife Lillian told the Eagle that she wanted "to forget it all.  I wish everybody would stop talking about it."  Unfortunately, people continue to talk about it to this day.  For in the words of the Eagle:

Eagle Clipping - Jan. 4, 1936


2/14/2009 11:41:41 AM #

Great post Leslie! So glad we have a real historian on board.


3/1/2009 11:48:02 PM #

In Footlight Parade, a movie from 1933, the final Busby Berkeley dance routine has the dancers seen from above in the shape of the NRA eagle. We do our part, indeed.


3/2/2009 10:36:46 AM #

Thanks for posting that bit of information, Matthew! I came across that particular dance number when I was doing my research, but the original movie wasn't identified. Now I know!


6/17/2012 7:48:24 AM #

Stupid, ignorant appalling post. FDR through the NRA was intent on keeping the price of food HIGH with government regulation. The Schechter brothers were American heroes, taking on the crushing,stupid New Deal to be allowed sell chickens. Go read some economic history & stop listening to unionised Democrat party propaganda "teachers". New Deal was a continuation of Hoover's disastrous borrow & spend policies which PROLONGED the depression until after the WWII.

Paddy Manning

6/17/2012 8:05:50 AM #

Nice to see you remove critical comments from your inaccurate post

Paddy Manning

6/17/2012 9:15:45 AM #

At the same time, criticisms of the NRA grew, not the least from the African-American community, which correctly saw attempts to raise wages as a means of shutting black labor out of the market. Writers at the Chicago Defender, the local black paper, referred to the NRA as the “Negro Run Around” and the “Negro Removal Act.” The NRA’s harm of black workers fits into a longer story how of labor market regulation was used for racist purposes. (See Art Carden and my October 2011 Freeman article, “Eugenics: Progressivism’s Ultimate Social Engineering.”)

Paddy Manning

6/17/2012 9:22:03 AM #

The Schechter brothers were heroes, fighting the clammy hand of FDR's recession prolonging New deal for the right to sell chicken to their customers in a way that observed Jewish Dietary law.
NIRA regulation RAISED the price of food at a time of unemployment & hunger.

Paddy Manning

6/17/2012 10:06:00 AM #

Suggesting that the  Schechters were unpatriotic is just shockingly wrong. FDR Administration painted them as stupid rubes, a tactic that backfired badly in the court as the brothers KNEW their business much better than FDR's commissars.

Paddy Manning

6/21/2012 4:30:49 PM #

Comments are moderated and may not appear immediately. We welcome informed and civil criticism; we publish the above comments despite the fact that they utterly fail to meet one of these standards.